Jan 23, 2009 Friday
Dear folks,
Check out (link...)
Check out (link...)
Check out (link...)
Check out Swan Pond Resident: (link...)
United Mountain Defense volunteers have been waiting to get new carpet put in the UMD volunteer house since we had an indoor flood on sunday night. We've still been helping organize between vacumming water and working with carpet specialists, and the insurance man.
So we have also been hounding TVA about the Material Safety Data Sheets AND WE FINALLY GOT A COPY OF IT TODAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The copies that we have are for Class F fly ash and for bottom ash. The main chemicals listed are aluminum oxide, iron oxide, calcium oxide, magnesium oxide, titanium oxide, and inorganic arsenic at varying ranges. We will try to get these sheets up on UMD's website and this blog.
We have also spent the day working on figuring out the air quality thing. WE HAVE GOOD NEWS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The Swan Pond community is so much further ahead than other coal impacted communities because of all their documentation, diaries, doctor's visits, and keeping track of their symptoms. The community listserve serves as a historical document because people keep posting their health issues there.
We have been working on formulating an air quality monitoring program. We want to bring down the Bucket Brigade? These are low volume air monitors that each citizen could recieve training to use. We could set them up inside local houses and also outside. We are looking into Summa containers to test for Volitile Organic Compounds and other gases. We are also looking into high volume air monitors and TEOM infra red scanning particulate monitors. CTEH/ TVA and TDEC are only testing to PM10 which is okay but we want to test for Total Suspended Particles which will give us a fuller air quality picture.
We have learned that TDEC has still not installed the two high volume air monitors they promised on Jan 15, 2009 but instead only installed one on Lake shore Drive. Can anyone verify that a big loud vaccum air monitor is plugged in to an electrical outlet out on Lakeshore drive with a smaller CTEH monitor next to it?
Yesterday I tried to find the air monitor on Berkshire Drive and only saw and video taped the small low volume CTEH/ TVA monitors. Is there a big air monitor plugged in to an electrical outlet there on Berkshire? So CTEH/ TVA is using low volume air monitors that would typically be used for indoors. The equipment they are using can not show compliance or non compliance with the EPA ambient air quality standards. Basically their equipment is too small. If you are so inclined you should call Tom Welborn of EPA at (404) 562 9354 and tell him that TVA is using low volume monitors to say they are achieving EPA ambient air quality standards. Request more high volume air monitoring equipment now. TELL HIM ABOUT THE HEALTH IMPACTS OF THE COMMUNITY including nose bleeds and respiratory problems. The air is also turning gold and silver jewelery black. Ask to file an official complaint.
Also call TDEC at (615) 532 0562 and tell them they need to order TVA to install more high volume air monitors as per the EPA's and TDEC's monitoring and reporting requirements. TDEC is the lead enforcement agency right now so we should focus our energies on them. Tell them about the communities health. Call TDEC and file a complaint, ask them to install more high volume air monitors.
Also we made a call today to OSHA about the fact that a lot of the independent contractors did not give TVA's MSDS sheets to their workers. These workers aren't informed about the toxins they are working with and their employers are not supplying them with the appropriate safety equipment. We called Phillip Harrell of OSHA at (615) 232 3803. OSHA needed to know the names of the contractors so that they could follow up on getting MSDS sheets out to the workers. Either call OSHA with the names of the contractors or email us and we will call them for you.
Also about the dump trucks tracking coal fly ash out onto the roads. We need to be more diligent about the trucks because we witnessed trucks traveling out of the disaster site without being washed. We were able to identify them because they had mud caked up on the sides, back, and wheel wells of the trucks. This has and will continue to be an ongoing problem for your community, but we can put a stop to it by reporting the dirty trucks. The following is a breif history of the dirty dump truck situation.
On Jan 6, 2009 Mr. Graves first video taped dirty dump trucks and made official complaints to the TN Highway Patrol, TDEC, EPA, TVA, and Howie Rose of Roane County Emergency Management Agency. On Jan 9, 2009 we reported dirty dump trucks. On Jan 12, 2009 Howie Rose told me TVA had purchased three truck washers to be installed. On Jan 15, 2009 we told Gill Francis of TVA not to forget the truck washers. On Jan 22, 2009 we called to report dirty dump trucks. As of Jan 23, 2009 TVA had still not installed the truck washers and Howie Rose said TVA will be installing them by this coming Tuesday Jan 27, 2009. This means that all of these agencies and TVA have knowingly been tracking coal fly ash out onto your roads for more than 17 days. This is unacceptable.
Please call TDEC (865) 594 6035
EPA (404) 562 9354
TN Highway Patrol (865) 594 5793
Howie Rose Roane County Emergency Management (865) 250 7347
TVA (865) 717 4006
File official complaints and make a paper trail for these injustices.
Alright, thanks for hanging in there.
I thank you for your help, support, courage, and kind words.
There is no shortage of a need for project funding. United Mountain Defense is a 501c3 and we are seeking funding or co-sponsoring organizations to help fund personal protection equipment, bottled water, independent air and water monitoring, and real time web cams.
If you are a resident impacted by TVA's coal ash disaster please contact us at 865 689 2778.
If you can make a donation of money or other resources please send a check to United Mountain Defense P.O. Box 20363 Knoxville, TN 37920 or use our PayPal account at (link...)
Till then ,matt landon full time volunteer staff person for United Mountain Defense
Topics:
|
Eco warriors and politics
- ‘Literally heartbreaking as a librarian’ 150 titles pulled from Rutherford County school libraries (TN Lookout)
- Trump’s Defense secretary nominee has close ties to Idaho Christian nationalists (TN Lookout)
- Top two Tennessee House Democrats retain caucus leadership (TN Lookout)
- Expecting challenges, blue states vow to create ‘firewall’ of abortion protections (TN Lookout)
- Community coalition issues demands for BlueOval City benefits, calls on Ford to negotiate (TN Lookout)
- Stockard on the Stump: Buy your hemp sticks before they clean the shelves (TN Lookout)
- Lawmaker accuses private-prison operator of celebrating potential boost in inmate population (TN Lookout)
- Federal agencies illegally okayed river dredging to restore railroad lost in Helene flooding (TN Lookout)
Science and stuff
- From electric cars to wildfires, how Trump may affect climate actions (Science News Daily)
- Dengue is classified as an urban disease. Mosquitoes don’t care (Science News Daily)
- Refurbished heart pacemakers work like new (Science News Daily)
- Ancient Central Americans built a massive fish-trapping system (Science News Daily)
- Satellite space junk might wreak havoc on the stratosphere (Science News Daily)
- Scientists identify a long-sought by-product of some drinking water treatments (Science News Daily)
- For adult chimps, playing may be more important than previously thought (Science News Daily)
- This is the first close-up image of a star beyond our galaxy (Science News Daily)
- Mars’ potato-shaped moons could be the remains of a shredded asteroid (Science News Daily)
- Here’s why turning to AI to train future AIs may be a bad idea (Science News Daily)
Discussing
- The Constitution Won, Trump Lost in Colorado...Now What? (1 reply)
- Our Very Own George Santos, TN GOP Congressman Ogles is Pretty Much Insane (1 reply)
- Destroying Jim Jordan, All Without Mentioning Jordan's Support For Sexual Abusing Athletes (1 reply)
- Want to See Who Owns Your State Senators and Reps? (1 reply)
- 9-11 Strangest Uninvestigated Fact (2 replies)
- It's Gettin' Real, Now...Gloria Johnson Made Wonkette! (1 reply)
- Does Rep Fritts Want School Shooters to Have Access to AR 15s? (2 replies)
- How many Trees Died Trying Save Us From Global Warming? (1 reply)
- Feel Good Friday,,,From our "If Only" Dept. (1 reply)
- Tennessee Education Worsens Under Bill Lee and GOP (1 reply)
- The Most Important Thing You Will Read Today! (1 reply)
- Friday Toons (1 reply)
Lost Medicaid Funding
Sponsors
Brother Websites
Local Interest:
Folks that Help:
Progressiveness:
- All Hat No Cattle
- American Progress
- Campaign for America's Future
- Daily KOS
- digby
- Paul Krugman
- Talking Points Memo
- Whitehouse.gov
Local News Media:
Local Government:
- City of Harriman
- City of Harriman Code
- City of Kingston
- City of Kingston Code
- City of Oliver Springs
- City of Oliver Springs Code
- City of Rockwood
- City of Rockwood Code
- Congressman Charles 'Chuck' J. Fleischmann
- Rep. Kent Calfee
- Rep. Ron Travis
- Roane County
- Roane Schools
- St. Sen. Ken Yager
Candidates:
If only it was that simple...
"paper trail for these injustices."
Injustices? How about logistics issues instead? Your word choice makes it seem like all that is happening is that all these listed people are conspiring to gether to do some unjust thing to all the residents of the area. Like they have all got together and said, "We'll not do this stuff, only tell them we'll do it. Cause we want to mess them over..."
As if!
Speaking of documentation: You have documentation of things you've asked for and things that haven't happened. Do you also have documentation that all these things are readily available and that all these people have just decided to stonewall you? Or is that something you are assuming without documentation. If you have the documentation of this being true, present it. If not, you may want to rethink the rhetoric a bit.
That documentation blade cuts both direrctions, you know.
Doing bad things to the people deliberately would be an injustice. Injustice, however, does not include failing to do things you ask for if that failure is caused by reasons you don't know of understand. Injustice is the wrong word, and use of such invective is one reason why folks tend to resist the things you want to do that are actually good things to do. The old thing about perception "being" reality is also a blade that cuts with both edges. If your choice of words lets you perceived as only looking for the worst in them, that's what you're likely to see.
RB
Definitions for the word injustice
RoaneBooster,
Thank you for your comment. I have thought about your ideas and decided to post the definitions of the word injustice. There are three that I found.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/injustice
Injustice
1 : absence of justice : violation of right or of the rights of another : unfairness
2 : an unjust act : wrong
synonyms injustice , injury , wrong , grievance mean an act that inflicts undeserved hurt. injustice applies to any act that involves unfairness to another or violation of one's rights
. injury applies in law specifically to an injustice for which one may sue to recover compensation
. wrong applies also in law to any act punishable according to the criminal code; it may apply more generally to any flagrant injustice . grievance applies to a circumstance or condition that constitutes an injustice to the sufferer and gives just ground for complaint .
http://www.brainyquote.com/words/in/injustice178819.html
Injustice
Want of justice and equity; violation of the rights of another or others; iniquity; wrong; unfairness; imposition.
An unjust act or deed; a sin; a crime; a wrong.
(link...)
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/injustice
Injustice
Violation of another's rights or of what is right; lack of justice.
A specific unjust act; a wrong.
SYNONYMS injustice, injury, wrong, grievance. These nouns denote acts or conditions that cause people to suffer hardship or loss undeservedly. An injustice is a violation of a person's rights; the term can also refer to unfair treatment of another or others: “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere” (Martin Luther King, Jr.). An injury is an injustice for which legal redress is available: The court awarded the plaintiff compensation for the injury to his property. Wrong is now more emphatic than injustice and in a legal sense refers to what violates the rights of an individual or adversely affects the public welfare: “The age of chivalry is never past, so long as there is a wrong left unredressed on earth” (Charles Kingsley). A grievance is regarded by those involved as a wrong that affords cause for complaint: The warden addressed the inmates' grievances.
Thank you for your time, matt landon
Very good! Nice discourse on injustice!
Your efforts are to be applauded.
However all these definitions or explanations of injustice demonstrate that an injustice is an act - or acts - that are deliberately undertaken for the purpose of inflicting the injustice. Injustice is not an accident.
That precludes the idea that desired or wanted or needed things that do not happen on the schedule of those who want them to happen cannot be classified as injustices unless they are deliberately acts of injustice. Injustice is not something that happens accidentally or outside the control of the one accused of perpetrating unjust acts.
So - in view of your assiduous attention to documenting all the phone calls demanding this or that from Howie Rose, TDEC, EPA, or whomever, I must presume that documentation is also present that demonstrates that your not already having received what you've asked for is the result of deliberate acts producing injustice, rather than the result of varying situations which may prevent the various entities from providing what you ask for at the drop of a hat.
I would point out that unless you know and have documented the motivation behind the fact that you do not have some of the items you asked for, than you may accurately be able to say "For some reason I do not yet know, they have not provided thus and so." But unless you know the situation or motivation behind the mere fact that the pieces of equipment you have demanded are not already there, all you have is an ASSUMPTION of the guilt necessary to make it an injustice. Injustice is not caused by logistic or supply problems. Having other tasks that have a higher priority for reasons you do not understand or have not asked about does not elevate the situation to an injustice.
Lacking something that you truly need or have an appropriate desire for does not, per se, rise to the level of an injustice, unless someone is deliberately keeping them from you in order to perpetrate an injustice. Deliberately keeping them from you when there is a reason for it, even though you may not understand the reason, does not elevate it to the level on an injustice.
Thanks for your time, and your efforts on behalf of Roane Countians who don't have the ability to help themselves.
RB
Thank you for your words and
Thank you for your words and time. I just wanted to let you know that United Mountain Defense and individuals including myself know that Roane county is full of kind, caring, devoted, smart, and hard working individuals who can take care of themselves. I am happy to work along side these folks and help out when I can. Thank you, matt landon full time volunteer staff person for United Mountain Defense
And thank you you, Matt
... for the good you work to bring to the table.
RB
Injustice-back to the big picture
I'd like to applaud UMD for using the correct word-injustice- to describe events related to the ashvalanche. The catastrophic failure of the ash pond dam and the subsequent inundation of almost 300 acres and the Emory River was a massive injustice to the community and to the river. The loss of homes, backyards, roads, farmland and a portion of the neighborhood river would have been injustice enough, but to add insult to injury the area is now covered with 5.4 million cubic yards of waste that contains heavy metals. From my perspective at least, this is not simply an injustice but rather is a gross injustice and a disaster.
RB, your penchant for picking out a small little detail in a post and focusing attention on it is only slightly instructive. The big picture injustice is what is important here, not your attack on one sentence in a post from a group doing good work for the community. Instead of constantly attacking people providing constructive services to the devastated community, why don't you pick out something positive and constructive you agree with and draw as much attention to that as you do to negative things you don't agree with. As you said, the blade cuts both directions. Why don't you start practicing what you preach?
That, kind sir, would be YOUR perspective
And it doesn't really matter if you choose to negate for yourself what I'm trying to say by throwing it away as "my penchant for picking out a small little detail."
In case you had not heretofore noticed, when it comes to things scientific and things legal (both of which apply to this incident), the devil IS in the details. Ignoring details gets causes bigger problems. You ignore them if your presepctive dictates that to you.
My perspective - which is as valid as anybody's perspective - remains that details DO make important differences.
I, too, applaud (as I stated) the positive espects of what UMD tries to do as an all volunteer group.
I don't have to repeat all the words I typed - I simply stand by what I said about injustice being - based on the "small little details" about how language is used - the wrong word to use.
Imprecision in language begets imprecision in thought which begets more imprecision in language which begets more imprecision in thought... And that simply leads to poor decisions and dumbing down both processes and populace. It erodes critical thinking abilities. Your personal perspective - to which you have an absolute right - notwithstanding, I don't submit to the idea that we need to engate in any process that impedes critical thinking.
Best to you,
RB
RB Once Again...
...You are exactly right. Your begetting synopsis is a fitting description of the chain of events that led to this catastophic injustice. Through your most eloquent statements you drew a visual portrait for me that goes something like this. TVA beget greed, which beget imprecision, which beget lack of critical thinking, which beget huge cash bonuses for TVA execs, which beget complacency, which beget recklessness and irresponsibility, which beget a catastrophic enviro and eco disaster, which beget injustice.
RB I just can't buy into the TVA is our upstanding friend theory. And I know that you didn't say that straight up, but you say it indirectly every time you come to TVA's defense, which is every time your hawk eye catches an anti-TVA movement in this forum. You pounce on it like a hawk on a prairie mouse. From my viewpoint TVA is not being 100% forthecoming. They have circled the wagons and are engaged in PR operations meant to downplay the catastrophic nature of this event. They are not giving their best effort in minimizing airborne contamination. The Emory River has become the forgotten frontier in spite of the fact that the Emory River has suffered the most damaging and long lasting affects of the spill. TVA is not dealing with affected property owners in a good faith manner. They are employing appraisers outside of the market area which are in turn lowballing property values to TVA's benefit. Property owners are going in mass to TVA at their beckon call yet TVA is not returning due diligence. In light of the fact that TVA has its blinders on and is campaigning to salvage its 50 acre gypsum pond which is located on a TVA designated WMA and across the lake from some pricy real estate, and in light of its obvious incapability to store ash responsibly I think it is fair to expect TVA to deal with property owners in a good faith manner and without reservation. There should be a set formula of 2x or 3x or whatever is deemed fair and then get into the business of expediting settlements so folks can get on with their lives as opposed to being held captive for indefinite periods of time. TVA is engaged in a cat & mouse game with individual property owners and its BS.